Why Do MarTech Teams Still Feel Like Order Takers?

If you're a MarTech leader, you've probably experienced some version of the same frustration. Your team owns critical systems, manages increasingly complex customer data, helps shape digital experiences, and is now being asked to play a leading role in AI initiatives. Yet despite all that responsibility, you can still find yourself treated as an implementation resource. The business arrives with a request, your team evaluates the options, builds the solution, and moves on to the next request. Meanwhile, strategic decisions too often happen elsewhere.

That tension formed the backdrop for a recent virtual meet-up ofRSG’s MarTech Leadership Council. The formal topic was organizational design, prompted by a case study from a corporate MarTech leader who had totally restructured her team. But as usually happens in these meetings, the conversation quickly expanded beyond the original agenda.

What began as a discussion about org charts became a broader exploration of influence, credibility, leadership, and the evolving role of MarTech inside large enterprises. I can’t share all the juicy tid-bits, since these are confidential conversations, but some broader-brush topics will pique your interest.

Start with Capabilities, Not Org Charts

One theme that emerged early in the discussion was the importance of focusing on business capabilities rather than organizational structures.

Many organizations inherit teams, platforms, and responsibilities that were created years earlier to solve different problems. Over time, those structures become accepted as fixed realities. Several participants noted that stepping back and focusing on the capabilities business stakeholders require can create a very different perspective on how teams should be organized and how work should be prioritized.

The conversation was less about identifying a single "best" organizational model and more about building teams that can adapt as business priorities evolve.

"Relationships Are Infrastructure"

The conversation became particularly animated when the topic shifted from structure to influence. One participant remarked that "relationships are infrastructure," a phrase that immediately resonated with the group.

The comment captured something that many MarTech leaders understand intuitively. Progress inside large organizations often depends on collaboration across multiple teams, functions, and stakeholders. Formal authority only goes so far, especially at a time when MarTech leaders need to align with foundational platform owners, particularly to succeed at AI.

Council participants shared experiences that reinforced a familiar lesson: successful initiatives often require alignment, trust, and shared objectives just as much as technical expertise. As MarTech responsibilities continue to expand, leaders increasingly find themselves relying on communication, influence, and relationship-building skills alongside their technical knowledge. Perhaps most importantly, this gives them the opportunity to sit in on strategic decision-making sessions happening upstream from their daily work.

AI Is Opening Doors

AI entered the discussion in an unexpected way.

Rather than focusing primarily on specific technologies or use cases, members spent considerable time discussing how AI is changing organizational priorities. Several attendees observed that initiatives that previously struggled to gain attention are now receiving renewed executive interest when viewed through the lens of AI readiness.

The details varied across organizations, but there was broad agreement that AI is creating new opportunities for MarTech leaders to engage in strategic conversations that might have been more difficult to initiate in the past.

The Leadership Challenge

The meeting eventually turned toward hiring and career development. Here again, the discussion moved beyond technology.

Participants explored questions around team design, leadership development, and the balance between specialized expertise and broader business ownership. Several members noted that as MarTech functions mature, leaders are increasingly looking for ways to develop strategic capabilities within their teams rather than focusing exclusively on platform-specific skills.

The conversation highlighted a challenge familiar to many organizations: how to create opportunities for talented practitioners to grow into broader leadership roles while continuing to support day-to-day execution. The team shared some really useful tips here.

What stood out most, though, was not any single conclusion, but the realization that leaders from very different industries were grappling with many of the same questions.

Why These Conversations Matter

The official topic for the session was MarTech organizational design. By the end of the discussion, however, the group had spent just as much time talking about influence, trust, leadership, and change. For me that’s not surprising, since most of our Council discussions transpire this way. Technology challenges facing MarTech teams remain significant, but many experienced leaders recognize that organizational dynamics often play an equally important role.

As always, the case-study presentation provided only part of the value. The richer insights came from the reactions, questions, and shared experiences that followed. Participants compared perspectives, challenged assumptions, and learned from peers facing similar pressures in different environments.

Article content
 

That's ultimately why these discussions matter. You arrive with a challenge that feels unique to your organization. Then you discover that many of your peers are working through similar issues.

If you're a MarTech leader wrestling with how to increase your team's strategic influence, you're certainly not alone. Our Council conversation suggests that many organizations are navigating the same transition.

Interested in joining the discussion? The RSG MarTech Leadership Council is an exclusive, confidential  peer group for senior MarTech leaders from RSG Member firms. Leaders like you meet several times a year to discuss strategy, technology, organizational design, and emerging trends with experienced peers from outside their industry. The goal is simple: learn from one another's successes, mistakes, and hard-earned lessons in a trusted environment.

Other Marketing Technology posts

Episode 16: Getting to MarTech 4.0

Tony and I talk about the concept of MarTech 4.0, explaining why enterprise organizations must move beyond siloed channel strategies toward unified data, content, decisioning, and orchestration.

On-demand Webinar: Strategic Lessons for MarTech Leaders

MarTech has evolved from an idea, to a stack, to a career path for enterprise leaders who can successfully bridge the domains of marketing, technology, and data. After supporting MarTech leaders for nearly two decades, RSG has distilled key strategic lessons to apply for the coming AI era.

On-demand Webinar: Selecting MarTech in an Era of AI Hype

What does MarTech selection look like in an era characterized by almost overwhelming AI messaging? How much does AI really matter to finding the best-fit platform and vendor? What do you need to do differently, and what remains tried-and-true?