There is STILL no such thing as a DXP

  • 23-Jan-2018

Late last year when Forrester announced a wave for "Digital Experience Platforms," we took them to task for favoring vendor hype over the interests of you the customer.  Now that Gartner has delivered a similar quadrant, let's once again review the key issues from your viewpoint.

DXPs Are for Wall Street, Not Main Street

For publicly-traded or late-stage venture-funded vendors, investors become more important constituents than customers.  Lately investors have been looking for "greater share of wallet" and vendors have been falling over themselves to show that their cross-selling strategies are working. 

The latest incarnation of this is "DXP," which can be defined in different ways, but typically entails some sort of hybrid Portal/CMS/DAM/Ecommerce/Personalization platform or collection of tools. Not every self-styled DXP offers all those services, let alone within the same product, but you get the idea. And it's a crazy idea (more about that below).

Gartner plays an outsized role in this process by fawning over the institutional demands of its largest vendor customers pushing this concept. 

Gartner on a Vendor Blender Bender

 Consider this Magic Quadrant.

MQ for DXP with RSG edits

At a high level this is an agglomeration of WCM, DAM, Portal, and Personalization vendors and tools.  Some are single products; some are huge, unweildy suites.

And what a bizarre potpourri of vendors and products.  For starters, you should be suspicious any chart that has both Salesforce and Squiz or Kentico and SAP together.  If you are looking at Sitecore and Liferay to solve the same problem, you should revisit your requirements or your vendor shortlist, or both.

There is no marketplace here, because no enterprise digital leader in her right mind would actually purchase "digital experience" as a platform.  DX is a strategy and approach, and no single platform or vendor on this chart will get you there. 

What You Should Do

First, be prepared for a lot of "selling up the chain," as large vendors try to persuade your boss that your reluctance to buy all their tools is somehow non-strategic. Real use-cases and business plans become your friend here. 

Every year I talk to hundreds of digital leaders.  Sometime you and I should discuss the various characteristics that accompany more successful digital strategies. But for now, let's just review one attribute: a rigorous approach to adopting best-fit technology, following a clear separation of concerns, to make sure digital teams have the right tools to execute on the organization's ambitions.

This takes discipline, a preference for integration over customization, and a clear understanding of the nexus of internal and customer usability.  It does not take a "digital experience platform."

 

Our customers say...

"The Web CMS Research is our reference work for web content management projects. It allows us to rapidly zero in on the right solution for each unique content management application. I can't imagine starting a new a project without it."

Alden Hart, CTO, Ten Mile Square Technologies

Other Web Content & Experience Management posts

Web CMS Tasting Notes

  • September 11, 2018

What if we could do simple "tasting notes" for certain WCM vendors, like wine critics do? What would we say? Quite tongue-in-cheek, here's a sampling...

The Sitecore Paradox

  • September 3, 2018

The vendor's focus on core R&D and channel-based selling proved a winning business strategy, but I think Sitecore has hit a ceiling in recent years....

What Is a Real Quadrant?

  • August 14, 2018

Customers and consultants have a love-hate relationship with marketplace "quadrant" diagrams. You suspect there's something not right in the arbitrary positioning...and you're correct!...

Thanks for the Book Reviews!

  • July 9, 2018

We wanted to take a moment to say a special thank you to a few people who took the time to write extended reviews of the book....

Is Salesforce the New SharePoint?

  • June 18, 2018

Like Microsoft, Salesforce has struggled to convert its employee-facing systems into effective customer-facing systems. Our research has found that enterprise licensees have encountered some nasty surprises around...

MD