Serena Collage to go off into the sunset

  • 12-Mar-2008

A Serena Collage customers' mailing lit up this morning with news that the software vendor (who focuses mostly on configuration management and mash-up tools) was going to discontinue development of its (somewhat hidden) Web CMS tool.

Evidently the news got leaked inadvertently, and Serena wasn't fully prepared to clarify. According to one customer, their account rep laid out a schedule whereby Serena would continue to sell new seat licenses for the next year, and then continue to offer paid support for another year. Serena will issue no new releases, just patches for issues of "the highest severity level."

In some ways, the tool was already suffering a long decline. As Web CMS Report readers know, Serena has not really invested much in Collage over the past few years, so at some level, this news was really a kind of a formality. Still, as you can imagine, some customers are angry and anxious, and a few have already received calls from competing vendors (bad news travels fast!).

Just remember though that products with a decent customer base don't go away easily. In all likelihood, Serena will sell its assets, among which the customer base may earn more than the code base. On the phone with a longtime Collage customer today, we reviewed potential scenarios:

  • Serena lets the product wither after two years and customers slowly migrate to competing technologies
  • Serena sells the product/customers to another Web CMS vendor -- not very comfortable for existing licensees unless the new owner commits to a second product rather than push them to migrate in a consolidation play
  • Serena sells the product/customers to a systems integration partner, who continues to support (and ideally extend) the tool -- a very nice outcome for customers if they know and trust the firm, and if the integrator can actually gear up to develop and support packaged software (not a simple undertaking)
  • Serena sells the product/customers to another software vendor that doesn't presently sell a Web CMS tool (like a document management vendor) -- very nice in theory, except when you remember that this is precisely how Collage ended up (and ended up unloved) at Serena in the first place
  • Serena puts the code base into open source and tells customers and partners to work it all out -- not a bad outcome, but probably perceived as high-risk among existing customers.


Customers facing a 1- to 2-year support window may find some comfort in Collage's relative ease of maintenance. Said that customer today, "I spent $10k a year to Serena for support and never needed it once."

And moreover, as a decoupled, HTML "baking" system that sits behind your website or web applications, licensees' visitor-facing services are not at risk here. As Web 2.0-style coupled architectures come back in vogue, it's worth reconsidering the value of good old fashioned separation of concerns.

Our customers say...

"The Real Story Group celebrates its 'vendor neutrality'. But it's not a neutrality that avoids taking positions. Far from it, their opinions are clearly stated, always well informed, and invariably fair."

Patricia Connelly, CEO at Henry Stewart Conferences and Events

Other Web Content & Experience Management posts

DAM Buyers Beware

  • July 16, 2018

Both Forrester and Gartner have published their quadrants or list of "Top DAM vendors" for 2018. For buyers' sake, I wish they had continued to ignore the space entirely....

Thanks for the Book Reviews!

  • July 9, 2018

We wanted to take a moment to say a special thank you to a few people who took the time to write extended reviews of the book....

Myths That MarTech Vendors Tell Themselves

  • July 6, 2018

Myths are important because they allow us to share common stories. They often have a foundation in the truth, but in a commercial context, they can become disconnected from reality...