Real Story Group. Make Better Technology Decisions.

Delivering fearless advice since 2001. Here's our story
What Real Independence means. Find Out

  • Free Sample
  • Contact
  • Subscriber Login
  • Your cart is empty.
Sign up for our Newsletter
  • Home
  • Research
  • Coverage Areas
  • Consulting
  • About
  • Blog
  • Buy Now
  • Recent Entries
  • Get Custom Feeds

 

 

 

Byrne Tony Byrne

Follow Tony on Twitter @TonyByrne

Don't ogle search if you really want content management

8-Jul-2010

I'll agree with mega-vendor Autonomy on one key point: Search technology is really important. But is it so important that search functionality should dominate your choice in a content management system? I don't think so. Search is one of many considerations.

The topic of search crops up one way or another in nearly all the advisory calls we receive from our research customers -- including inquiries about other technologies, like ECM, Portals, Web CMS, DAM, and so forth. Search is essential; search is omnipresent; but woe to project leader who believes search engines are omniscient. Of course, this doesn't stop enterprise search vendors from claiming omnipotence.

Which brings me back to Autonomy. From an initial focus on enterprise search tools, Autonomy has become a roll-up vendor after acquiring a variety of other information management suppliers such as Interwoven. As a financial strategy this can be successful, and investors seem to cotton to Autonomy.

As a technology strategy, vendor roll-ups are problematic. Autonomy's technology strategy is to rip legacy search subsystems from acquired products, replace them with some pieces from its own IDOL toolset, and then promote its particular approach to search as a distinct advantage for you.

Specifically, Autonomy will try to sell you on the value of "meaning-based computing." Even if you can get your mind around what meaning-based means, you should remain skeptical that Autonomy has technically spectacular or original services here. More importantly, you risk getting sidetracked from your original goal of, say, creating a user-friendly repository for your 50,000 Office documents.

This wouldn't be as big a problem if Autonomy hadn't acquired so many aging technologies, especially in the WCM and DAM segments. Don't be surprised when, upon asking about missing or substandard functionality in these areas, your Autonomy reps deflect with search-oriented -- oops, I mean "meaning-oriented" -- answers.

Now, if you're buying a DAM, Records Management, or Web CMS package, you can't sneeze at better search, but in Autonomy's case it comes with some very complex and maintenance-intensive technology in IDOL. It also invites a slew of upsells of nearly limitless optional modules. Before long, you've turned a content management project into a serious search investment. Autonomy's delighted, but is that what you really intended?

Again, search is important -- but in the context of a broader content management effort, search becomes a complementary service. So when you examine Autonomy's toolsets, best to ignore all the talk about IDOL unless what you're really looking for is an enterprise search platform. When evaluating Autonomy offerings across the many marketplaces where it sell products, we continue to look carefully at what each package was actually intended to do. You should too.

    Excerpt from the Autonomy TeamSite Evaluation

    Web Content Management Evaluation Stream looks at... Overselling TeamSite

    "You need to be careful here. Systems integrators who work with multiple CMS vendors routinely cite Autonomy/Interwoven salespeople as the most aggressive in the industry, especially when it comes to bundling extra products that a customer may not need, or..."
    (p. 171)

    Get All CMS Vendor Evaluations

    Learn the real strengths and weaknesses of major CMS vendors from around the world, in our Web Content & Experience Management evaluation research stream.

Tweet

Tags: Brand & Digital Asset Management, Document Management (ECM), Enterprise Collaboration & Social Software, Enterprise Search, Portals & Content Integration, Web Content & Experience Management, Information Architecture, Marketplace at Large, Selecting Technology, , Autonomy TeamSite, IDOL Server, iManage WorkSite, Virage MediaBin

close x

Free Sample Request

  Brand & Digital Asset Management
  Broadcast & Media Asset Management
  Cloud File Sharing & Collaboration
  Digital Marketing Technology
  Document Management (ECM)
  Enterprise Collaboration & Social Software
  Enterprise Search
  Evaluating SharePoint
  Portals & Content Integration
  Web Content & Experience Management
Is your interest or need urgent?
 Sign up to stay up-to-date on the latest news and webinars from RSG.
Your personal information, including your e-mail address, will be held in the strictest of confidence and will never be shared with anyone.

Subscriber Log In

Remember Me
Forgot password?
Not a subscriber?
Learn about our subscriptions

Research Mentioned in this Post

CMS Vendor Evaluations

Learn the real strengths and weaknesses of 37 major Web CMS products from around the world.

|

Our Customers Say...

"Your CMS research saved us money and efforts in identifying the right WCMS provider for our local market."

Eng. Moath Abdullah AL-Manayes, Executive Manager, Kuwait Neshami Company W.L.L.

next More

Stay in Touch

Get the Real Story bi-weekly.

Have Questions?

USA & Canada
+1 800 325 6190

UK
+44 (0) 20 3318 1911

International
+1 617 340 6464


All Other Inquiries

Real Story Group

Follow us on:  RSS  |  Twitter  |  Facebook  |  YouTube

Coverage Areas

  • Web Content & Experience Management
  • Brand & Digital Asset Management
  • Broadcast & Media Asset Management
  • Document Management (ECM)
  • Enterprise Collaboration & Social Software
  • Portals & Content Integration
  • Enterprise Search
  • Evaluating SharePoint
  • Cloud File Sharing & Collaboration
  • Digital Marketing Technology

Premium Research

  • Compare Research Programs
  • Advisory Papers & Webinars
  • Vendors Evaluated
  • Build a Custom ShortList
  • Schedule Analyst Consultation
  • Download Immediately

About Us

  • Our Methodology
  • Our Team
  • Media
  • Customer List
  • Events
  • Consulting Services
  • Contact Us

Need Help?

  • Talk to an Expert
  • FAQs
  • Customer Support
  • Contact Sales Team
  • Help with your account

Copyright Real Story Group 2001 - 2013. All rights reserved.

  • Contact Us
  • Copyright Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Log In

Remember MeForgot password?

close x
close x

All analyst firms claim to be independent or vendor-neutral. We're different.

Real Independence


Get the real story on commercial and open source tools from a firm that works only for you, the technology customer.

close x

Newsletter Signup

Thank you for signing up for The Real Story Group Newsletter. You will receive our monthly newsletter, plus updates with new information on the technology streams you have expressed interest in below.










Choose the streams that you’d like to receive updates for: