Real Story Group. Make Better Technology Decisions.

Delivering fearless advice since 2001. Here's our story
What Real Independence means. Find Out

  • Free Excerpt
  • Contact
  • Subscriber Login
  • Your cart is empty.
Sign up for our Newsletter
  • Home
  • Research
  • Coverage Areas
  • Consulting
  • About
  • Blog
  • Buy Now
  • Recent Entries
  • Get Custom Feeds

 

 

 

Pelz-Sharpe Alan Pelz-Sharpe

De-mystifying the Gartner ECM Magic Quadrant

28-Sep-2007

Late last year we blogged on the 2006 Gartner Magic Quadrant (MQ) for ECM - and made the point that inclusion in the chart is believed by vendors to have a very positive impact on their sales.

In the 2007 MQ - published this past week - it's clear that little (in Gartner's view) has changed in the ECM world. Well, we beg to differ: 2007 has been a period of major change! And so rather than harping on perceived weaknesses in this highly influential document, let's point out where the analysis in our ECM Suites Report differs from Gartner's.

  1. CMS Watch recognizes that there are valid and increasingly plausible and popular open source options for ECM making an impact on the market as a whole. Alfresco, Nuxeo, Knowledge Tree, Jahia and InfoGrid are all credible options. Yet not even a mention of Alfresco (who have been almost ubiquitous in the press this year) is made in the Gartner report.
  2. We see regional richness and diversity amongst ECM suppliers around the globe. Look for example at the impact of NewGen in India, Asia and the Middle East - or Saperion in Europe. Neither of whom get a mention.
  3. We don't grade vendors on the size of their revenue -- rather on their viability and the quality of their products. Many products make less than $20 Million a year (a criteria for inclusion in the MQ), yet are profitable, stable, and produce very high quality products.
  4. We differentiate vendors by scenarios, i.e., by where their product would be best suited. For example Cimage, Spescom and Formtek (only Cimage is included in the MQ) might all be prime candidates in an Engineering DM situation. Vendors have both domain expertise and products that have been designed to excel in some situations but not others. We think it's important that you know those differences and are able to compare like for like before selecting a shortlist based on vague concepts such as "leadership and vision."

 

There are other things about this report that baffle us - like why SAP is included in it, when even the report itself states that they do not have an ECM Suite - when others that do sell ECM Suites (such as those we mention above) are excluded. It may seem unfair to pick on another analyst firm - and for the record the authors of this particular report are all experts we have great respect for - but the importance of the MQ in the buying process is so huge that it demands a critical assessment and evaluation.

If there is a problem to identify, it is likely a business model that hinges on such charts, and a public's demand for ever simplified information, along with the vendors addiction to getting the "right" placement in the chart. It is both the beauty and the curse of the MQ that it dramatically simplifies a marketplace. But ECM tools and choices are far from simple. In short, buyers of ECM beware.

    Excerpt from the Drupal Commons Evaluation

    Enterprise Collaboration & Social Software Evaluation Stream looks at... Customizations of Drupal

    "Configuration management becomes a nightmare when dealing with multiple environments such as development-staging-production or multiple development environments. These kinds of customizations need to be hand-applied to every environment. ..."
    (p. 250)

    Get All Vendor Evaluations

    Learn the real strengths and weaknesses of major vendors from around the world, in our evaluation research stream.

Tweet

Tags: Document Management (ECM), Marketplace at Large, Open Source, Selecting Technology

close x

Free Sample Request

  Brand & Digital Asset Management
  Broadcast & Media Asset Management
  Cloud File Sharing & Collaboration
  Digital Marketing Technology
  Document Management (ECM)
  Enterprise Collaboration & Social Software
  Enterprise Search
  Evaluating SharePoint
  Portals & Content Integration
  Web Content & Experience Management
Is your interest or need urgent?
 Sign up to stay up-to-date on the latest news and webinars from RSG.
Your personal information, including your e-mail address, will be held in the strictest of confidence and will never be shared with anyone.

Subscriber Log In

Remember Me
Forgot password?
Not a subscriber?
Learn about our subscriptions

Research Mentioned in this Post

Vendor Evaluations

|

Our Customers Say...

"The Web CMS Research is excellent! Very well written, and you've done a masterful job explaining the business case for WCM."

Peter Morville, Consultant, Author, Information Architecture for the World Wide Web

next More

Stay in Touch

Get the Real Story bi-weekly.

Have Questions?

USA & Canada
+1 800 325 6190

UK
+44 (0) 20 3318 1911

International
+1 617 340 6464


All Other Inquiries

Real Story Group

Follow us on:  RSS  |  Twitter  |  Facebook  |  YouTube

Coverage Areas

  • Web Content & Experience Management
  • Brand & Digital Asset Management
  • Broadcast & Media Asset Management
  • Document Management (ECM)
  • Enterprise Collaboration & Social Software
  • Portals & Content Integration
  • Enterprise Search
  • Evaluating SharePoint
  • Cloud File Sharing & Collaboration
  • Digital Marketing Technology

Premium Research

  • Compare Research Programs
  • Advisory Papers & Webinars
  • Vendors Evaluated
  • Build a Custom ShortList
  • Schedule Analyst Consultation
  • Download Immediately

About Us

  • Our Methodology
  • Our Team
  • Media
  • Customer List
  • Events
  • Consulting Services
  • Contact Us

Need Help?

  • Talk to an Expert
  • FAQs
  • Customer Support
  • Contact Sales Team
  • Help with your account

Copyright Real Story Group 2001 - 2013. All rights reserved.

  • Contact Us
  • Copyright Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Log In

Remember MeForgot password?

close x
close x

All analyst firms claim to be independent or vendor-neutral. We're different.

Real Independence


Get the real story on commercial and open source tools from a firm that works only for you, the technology customer.

close x

Newsletter Signup

Thank you for signing up for The Real Story Group Newsletter. You will receive our monthly newsletter, plus updates with new information on the technology streams you have expressed interest in below.










Choose the streams that you’d like to receive updates for: